Jump to Navigation

SCOTUS looks at insurance benefits in divorce

Divorce is the legal process by which a marriage contract is dissolved. Anyone who has been through the process knows that it can tend to get complicated. The older a divorcing couple happens to be, the more intertwined their assets are. That can require finding solutions for dividing property that require zigging and zagging through assets to achieve an equitable balance. If some individual asset happens to fall through a crack, it can trigger disputes later that only the courts can resolve.

Just such a case has arrived at the U.S. Supreme Court. Because of similarities in the laws that are in effect in Texas and the state from which the case originates, we are sure attorneys across the Lone Star state will be watching to see the outcome.

The issue

At its core, the question before the high court is whether a so-called revocation-upon-divorce statute can be applied retroactively to a contract signed years before the law was enacted, or whether such a law violates the Contracts Clause of the U.S. Constitution.

The details of the case out of Minnesota are these. A husband contracted for a life insurance policy in 1998 and named his then-wife as the beneficiary. Nine years later, the couple divorced, but the husband never removed his wife as the designee. The legal bump in the road is that in 2002, state law was changed to add a provision stating that a divorce settlement automatically revokes life insurance beneficiary designations.

When the ex-husband died in 2011, both the ex-wife and the man's adult children made claim to the insurance payout. The initial court decision went to the children, but an appeals court reversed in favor of the ex-wife earlier this year. The panel of judges invalidated the retroactive application of the 2002 revocation-upon-divorce statute to the 1998 insurance policy - noting the Contracts Clause of the Constitution forbids a state law from breaching a contract.

There is no predicting how the Supreme Court will ultimately rule on this matter. What is clear is that because most states in the country have similar revocation-upon-divorce statutes, the decision could have a significant impact.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Avvo client choice award 2017
Subscribe to this blog's feed

Attorney Christine K. Lincoln

Christine K. Lincoln offers sound counsel and legal services to protect clients and their families facing divorce and other family disputes.

She will take the time to understand your individual needs and develop a comprehensive solution to protect your rights and interests.

Email Us

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Office Location

The Lincoln Law Firm, PLLC
12777 Jones Road, Suite 475
Houston, TX 77070
Phone: 281-970-9005
Fax: 832-645-7666
Map and Directions

Texas Divorce Attorneys, Mental Health Professionals, & Financial Planners
FindLaw Network